Update:
Well when you are wrong, you're wrong. My initial thought of bad customer service was remedied when a representative reached out to me and offered to send a free pair of boots. I was surprised so asked for the same brown color when, in hindsight, I probably should have asked for a different color. The new boots seem to be the same as the old ones though the squeak is much less. Honestly, I'm just impressed they reached out to make it right. For the effort, they get 5 stars from me.
Original review:
So I actually do really like these boots. I got the brown ones and they are a beautiful, rich dark brown. There are 2 reasons for the 3 stars. The first, and major, reason why is because of the noise. Jesus take the wheel….these shoes make a racket. The leather is the squeakest thing I have ever heard. The leather tongue rubs against the sides of the boot which causes multiple squeak noises which happen while walking, while putting the boots on, while breathing. It's just….wow. I have to apologize while walking by people and I never have to worry about startling someone because they can hear me walking towards them.
I have tried a few things to remedy the squeak. I hoped maybe I could break them in and the squeaking would lessen. Nope. I've tried lotion. Nope. My next option is to buy some leather conditioner and hope that helps but at this point, my coworkers are getting use to it. No snake in the grass here. They hear my squeaky self miles away.
The other noise complaint is the zipper is on the outside of the boot which does make taking it off the first time surprising. However, when you walk the….zipper handle…thing…clinks against the zipper part. So not only am I squeaking…I'm jingling as I do it.
The reason for the 2nd star off is because of the customer service. Talk about a copy and paste system. I contacted them asking if they had any advice, maybe a certain type of leather conditioner that might help. Their response was "oops. Sorry you don't like it. Here's 40% off if you want to buy them again. Feel free to keep the original pair." Like…thanks? So I get to keep the squeaky boots I paid for and then should buy another pair? Why? Just in case I want to see what the squeak is like in black? The customer service is bad.
To conclude, they are noisy, the zipper is kind of janky and at first it doesn't work well but with use it gets much easier. I am not mad about getting these boots though. They were $36 and even if I have to spend $10 on leather conditioner, they would still be under $50 which most boots like this are over that. I'll see how they hold up and update if anything interesting happens.